How to Vet a Roofer Before the First Prairie Storm Hits
A Working Roofer’s Guide to Sorting the Crews Worth Calling from the Ones that Vanish in October
By Nathan Washington, W Contracting
Every spring the phone starts ringing in Saskatoon, and every spring I hear the same story. Somebody hired a crew off a flyer, paid a deposit and never saw them again once the weather turned. It happens more than it should. Roofing is one of those trades where the bad work looks fine for a year or two, right up until the first real melt sends water into a ceiling. By then the crew that did it is long gone.
So this is less a sales pitch than a walk through what I would check if I were the one standing in my driveway deciding who gets the job.
Start With Who Actually Shows Up
Ask who will be on your roof. Not the salesperson, the actual crew. A lot of outfits sell the work and then hand it to whoever is cheap and available that week. That is where quality slips. You want a company that runs its own people, or at least uses the same subs year after year and stands behind them. On the Prairies especially, experience with our freeze-thaw cycle matters. A roof that goes up fine in July can still fail if the installer does not understand how ice moves under shingles in February.
When you are hiring roofers in Saskatoon, the boring questions tell you the most. How long have they worked this city. Can they point you to a job a few streets over. Do they answer the phone in the evening when a homeowner is worried about a drip. None of that shows up on a glossy ad.
Insurance and Paperwork, Before Anything Goes on the Roof
Get the Green Building Project Checklist
Use this handy checklist on your next project to keep track of all the ways you can make your home more energy-efficient and sustainable.
Two kinds of insurance matter here, and people mix them up. The contractor needs their own liability coverage and workers compensation, so that if somebody gets hurt on your property it is not your problem. Ask for proof, not a promise. A real company will send it without flinching.
The second kind is your own. Saskatoon gets hail, and hail claims are their own animal. A roofer who works storm damage should be able to sit at your kitchen table and walk you through how a claim actually goes, what the adjuster looks for, and where homeowners tend to get tripped up. Be careful with anyone who offers to handle the deductible for you or pushes you to sign over your claim before they have even been up top. That is a bad sign, and in some cases it crosses a line you do not want to be on the wrong side of.
Read the Quote Like a Contract, Because it is One
A cheap number on a scrap of paper is not a quote. A proper estimate says what is being torn off, what is going back on, how the flashing and valleys are handled and what happens if they open up the deck and find rot underneath. That last part catches people. Old roofs hide soft plywood, and a crew that has not written anything about it in the quote will spring a surprise charge on you mid-job.
Match the materials to the house and the climate, not to whatever the salesperson is pushing this month. Asphalt shingle still makes sense for most homes. Metal is a longer play and handles snow load and shedding well, though it costs more up front. Flat sections and rubber membrane are a different skill again. The right roofer will tell you plainly which one fits your roof instead of selling you the most expensive option on the truck.
Warranties Are Only as Good as the Company
There are two warranties on almost every roof. The manufacturer covers the shingles themselves and that paper is usually solid. The one that actually protects you is the workmanship warranty from the installer, because most leaks come from how the roof was put together, not from a defective shingle. A workmanship warranty from a crew that will not exist next spring is worth nothing. So the question loops back to the first one. Is this a company that has been here, and plans to stay here.
Local Knowledge Is Not a Marketing Line
Saskatoon roofs take a beating that a lot of the country never sees. We swing from deep cold to bright sun in the same week, ice dams build along eaves, and a July storm can drop hail the size of a toonie on the whole east side. Crews that work Warman, Martensville and the towns out towards Rosthern deal with the same thing on rural exposures with more wind. A roofer who has spent years in this weather installs differently. They pay attention to underlayment, to ventilation in the attic, to how the eavestrough carries meltwater away from the fascia. That is the stuff you never see and the stuff that decides whether your roof lasts fifteen years or thirty.
None of this needs to be complicated. Slow down, ask plain questions, get the paperwork, and trust the crew that talks straight over the one that talks fast. A roof is the one part of the house that protects everything else. It is worth getting the hire right.
If you are unsure where to start, write down your questions before you call anyone. The good crews will be glad you did.
Images from Depositphotos
